On November 18, 2026, the Competition Bureau announced it has obtained an order from the Federal Court of Canada to advance its ongoing investigation into marketing practices at Old Navy and Gap, both Gap Inc. brands. The order requires Old Navy and Gap to produce records and written information relevant to the investigation.
The Bureau is examining these practices under the deceptive marketing provisions of the Competition Act.
Practices Under Review
-
Regular prices: whether they are genuine when products are advertised as on sale
-
Urgency cues: limited-time offers and countdown timers or clocks
-
Scarcity messages: claims that products are in short supply, such as "Selling Fast" or "Only a Few Left"
-
Popularity claims: displays of how many people are viewing or buying a product
-
Past prices or discounts: claims such as "Price Drop" or "Best Deal in 30 days"
Why This Matters for Apparel Brands and Retailers
This investigation targets practices that are standard across apparel e-commerce. The Bureau has signalled this focus before. In 2025, after a surge in complaints about inflated regular prices, it warned businesses of their obligations under the Competition Act. In 2024, during Black Friday, it issued a consumer alert about fake urgency cues. The timing of this announcement, ahead of Black Friday and the holiday season, is deliberate.
Financial exposure is significant, and enforcement no longer rests with the Bureau alone. Since June 20, 2025, private parties can seek leave to bring deceptive marketing cases before the Competition Tribunal. See the penalty overview below.
Recommended Actions
-
Validate "regular" prices. A regular price used in a savings claim must meet one of two tests: a substantial volume of the product sold at that price (Bureau guidance: more than 50% of units over the prior 12 months), or the product was offered at that price in good faith for a substantial period (more than 50% of the time over the prior six months).
-
Audit urgency and scarcity tools. Countdown timers must reflect real deadlines. Stock and popularity indicators must reflect real, current data.
-
Check "lowest price" and "price drop" claims against documented pricing history.
-
Keep records. As this case shows, the Bureau can compel production of pricing and marketing records by court order.
-
Review holiday campaigns now, before Black Friday promotions launch.
CAF will monitor this investigation and report developments to members.
Penalty Provisions of the Competition Act: Pricing Claims
1. What counts as a pricing violation (s. 74.01)
-
General misrepresentation, s. 74.01(1)(a): any public representation that is false or misleading in a material respect, made to promote a product or business interest.
-
Ordinary selling price, your own prices, s. 74.01(3): a savings claim based on a regular price is reviewable unless the business shows it sold a substantial volume at that price or higher, or offered it in good faith for a substantial period. The burden of proof sits with the business.
-
Ordinary price, market-wide claims, s. 74.01(2): the same tests apply to claims about the price competitors usually charge. Here the Bureau must show neither test was met.
-
Timing, s. 74.01(4): whether the test period runs before or after the claim depends on whether it concerns prices already charged or prices to be charged.
-
Saving clause, s. 74.01(5): the volume and time tests do not apply if the business shows the price claim is not materially false or misleading in the circumstances.
-
Drip pricing, s. 74.01(1.1): quoting a price that cannot be attained because of fixed obligatory charges or fees is false or misleading. Charges imposed only under federal or provincial law are excluded.
2. Civil remedies (s. 74.1)
-
Prohibition order: stop the conduct or any substantially similar conduct. Orders last ten years unless the court sets a shorter period.
-
Corrective notice: a published notice naming the business, the conduct, the period, the area and the media used.
-
Administrative monetary penalties:
-
Corporations: up to the greater of 10million(15 million for each subsequent order) or three times the benefit derived. If the benefit cannot be reasonably determined, the cap is 3% of annual worldwide gross revenues.
-
Individuals, including officers and directors: up to the greater of 750,000(1 million for each subsequent order) or three times the benefit derived.
-
Restitution: available for misrepresentations under s. 74.01(1)(a). The amount cannot exceed what the business received for the products. It is distributed to purchasers, excluding wholesalers, retailers and other distributors to the extent they resold the products.
3. How penalty amounts are set (s. 74.1(5))
The court must weigh:
-
how far the conduct reached, and how often and how long it ran
-
how vulnerable the affected consumers were, and how material the representation was
-
gross revenue from affected sales and the firm's financial position
-
the firm's compliance history
-
refunds or compensation already paid
The stated purpose is to promote compliance, not to punish.
4. Defence
No corrective notice, AMP, or restitution order may be made if the business shows it exercised due diligence to prevent the conduct. The court can still issue a prohibition order. A documented pricing-compliance program is the practical basis for this defence.
5. Who can bring a case
The Commissioner of Competition, or a private party granted leave by the Competition Tribunal under s. 103.1. Private access to deceptive marketing cases has been in force since June 20, 2025.
6. Criminal track (s. 52)
Where a misrepresentation is made knowingly or recklessly, it is a criminal offence. The prosecution need not prove that anyone was actually deceived. Penalties:
-
On indictment: a fine at the court's discretion, imprisonment for up to 14 years, or both.
-
On summary conviction: a fine of up to $200,000, imprisonment for up to one year, or both.
The Bureau handles most pricing cases on the civil track. The criminal track is used for deliberate or flagrant conduct.